IMJUSTCREATIVE aka Graham Smith

Seaford Based Freelance Designer & Blogger / Over 20 Years Commercial Experience in Design, Marketing & Print / Evolving Ideas to Print and Digital Media
ImJustCreative / Graham Smith / Seaford Based Freelance Designer header image 1

How often do you hear the same ‘blogging’ message?

Alfriston, April 2005I have recently witnessed (makes me seem so important!) some Blogs where people have left casual (or even sinister) comments saying that they have read a similar article elsewhere (they do say it’s a small world after all). Well, there’s news for me. Then going as far as accusing the writer of stealing that very content. Fair enough I say if it is a blatant ‘copy and paste’, without any citing of the original article or owner, but for me it is often apparent that this is just not the case.

The articles I have read have been informative and valuable to me in my own quest to assimilate as much of the information out there, there being the (Blogosphere).

With the hopeless notion that I may myself be able to present a Blog that people will hopefully come back and visit from time to time. The Blogosphere is a huge depository of information (or library), which needs to be admired and also respected.

So reading these comments, I decided to check out these ‘other’ Blogs, where this article was supposedly ripped from. Well, for a start it was not a blatant RIP. Which is the most important thing, copying word for word is not so proper at the end of the day. In fact it’s just darn rude.

Which then leads me to think what these commentators were getting at exactly? Personally it sounded very much like they were implying that when Blog A talks about Subject A that Bloggers B-Z are then excluded about talking about Subject A as this would be seen as copying.

This astounds me no end and demonstrates a naivety beyond words.

If you applied this to News, TV’s and Radio shows, this would mean that the first person to break the news had the monopoly on it. Simply not cool.

So why should this particular Blogger get the brunt of this shallow thinking. God knows. All I know is that I probably would not of come across this particular article had it not been for this particular Blog. It was an incredibly valuable article and proved to help me no end (something about garage shelving I think). Subsequently I visited the article that was referred by the commentators as being the said ‘ripped off blog. Not even word for word, just a similar topic. So I read this and got some further valuable information (about garage shelving) that had not been covered in detail in the latter blog posting. Great for me (and my garage).

It’s all about choice.

Having the same subject raised in multiple Blogs is so very important, and commentators who have nothing better to do than to criticise about decent Blogs spreading informative information so that the greatest number of people can access it is what it’s all about.

At about the same time I posted this, I got a email update from Blog about Your Blog a post about something vaguely similar, so there are some interesting comments over there about, ermmm, Blogging about Blogging that someone else has Blogged about. Eh?

This wasn’t a one off for me either. I have come across it a number of times and started to leave me thinking is this what readers desire? Always original material, that to copy or mimic or help spread the word would be deemed as inappropriate and borderline copyright infringement? Hmmm.

If an article that is deemed to be genuine and not specifically news worthy, and a Blogger decided to use this material in his Blog as well, then a few words saying where they saw the original article is all that is needed. This keeps the original blogger happy and shows your respect by spreading the word. Everyone is happy.

Going through a crisis with social networks. So many conflicting, positive suggestions about all this that it can really send your head into a spin.

I have read a couple articles in the last month that have echoed what other Bloggers have said in a manner of speaking. Which is good as it helps me define my priorities, and also says to me that a number of my more ‘trusted’ sources are on the same wavelength which is confidence inspiring.

That you are all not trying to preach your own message just for the sake of being different.

There is nothing wrong in seeing the same message, as this helps reinforce the message, especially when it’s along the lines of advice.

I am happy to spread the word when I read an informative article. If it is something that I can relate to, and had I had the foresight myself to talk about it then re-enforcing this message by repeating it compliments the original poster. You are showing your gratitude for the original article. As long as you Trackback or link to the original post then all is cool. You have a great post and the original poster is happy as he is linked to and will no-doubt benefit from this.



6 comments ↓

#1 RT Cunningham on 02.14.08 at 3:32 pm

Stopped by to scratchback as well as see what you have. Nice article. Accusations get hurled mainly by those without experience. Hot topics get written by so many people in a short span of time, there’s bound to be overlaps, references, etc.

Imitation is flattery whereas pure plagiarism is not. People need to learn to distinguish between the two.

#2 impNERD on 02.15.08 at 10:42 pm

Totally agree with you here. In most cases even what the top bloggers blog about was first blogged somewhere else, even though they receive credit.

#3 Graham on 02.15.08 at 11:08 pm

RT & IMPNERD> Many thanks for leaving a comment. This is a new Blog for me even though I have imported many posts from one of my older Blogs, it’s only been up for a month or so.

Still finding my voice really, trying not to push myself into to many corners, just going to see how it pans out. Plenty of ideas, its already far from what I imagined, in a good way, so it’s evolving.

I know some blogs launch with a clear focused message… not me. Im just drifting… :)

Really value your comments.

Shame my top commentators plug-in is not working otherwise you would be up there as well. And thats another story.

Graham

#4 Graham on 02.15.08 at 11:24 pm

Hey Chaps:
Have a small favour. I am trying this ‘commentluv’ plugin which I have seen on some other blogs which I think is a great way to encourage commentators and they get something back from it.

Could you please both just leave a post each, blank if you want, as I need to see if this really works as it should.

Many thanks,

#5 Alpay Erturkmen on 02.21.08 at 3:44 pm

Hi Graham,

You got a nice thing taking off here, I wish you good luck with your new adventure.

On the sinister comments of content stealing, I believe those comments are very much like bees jumping from plant to plant spreading the seeds for them. Luckily one can get different opinions on the same subject because of these blog bees :)

Have a nice day…

Alpay Erturkmen’s last blog post..Local Wordpress Installation

#6 Graham on 02.21.08 at 3:53 pm

Hi Alpay
Thanks for leaving a comment for me today. I just hopped over to your Blog and being a Mac chap for some 20 years, surprised I haven’t stumbled across your blog sooner.

Will sign up to your feed, as I like reading different takes on the Mac culture.

Blog bee’s eh? I like that phrase. :0)

Regards
G

Leave a Comment

Profilactic Lifestream Subscriber Logo All my Feeds in one place @ Profilactic. Profilactic is one Uber collection of lifestream' feeds. Subscribe or follow 'most' of my relevant Feeds, including: Del.ici.ous, Twitter, Tumblr, FaceBook, Pownce, Flickr to name but a few. All my Lifestream and Blog Feeds in one place also at FriendFeed.

FREE Chicklets & Badges

jaiku linkxhtml w3c validate logo xhtml w3c validate logo

powered by Twitter logo Fuzz Chicklet logo designer by Graham Smith, freelance Graphic Designer based in Seaford, East Sussex Wordpress logo

Twitter about...

  • Working on some new CrowdSpring projects, damn the compettion is hot 1 week ago
  • URL for CrowdSpring here, cut off the other one. http://snurl.com/2udfh 1 week ago
  • Have some logos over at CrowdSpring that could do with some voting if you like them, a mosquito company (ImJustCreative) http://snurl.co ... 1 week ago
  • Been using LinoType's FontExplorer for my Mac's font management. It's very good, and its free! Been using for several weeks now. No issu ... 1 week ago
  • Some more success's on CrowdSpring, so confidence is growing. Can be a very tough place to work on, but can be rewarding. Very up and down. 1 week ago
  • Thanks all so much for voting on CrowdSpring. Up against the best on that one, so not at all hopeful, but all good practice with Illustr ... 3 weeks ago
  • More updates...

Posting tweet...

All content © ImJustCreative / Graham Smith / Seaford Based Freelance Designer | Visualization is a Wordpress magazine theme by Thad Allender. Theme modified by ImJustCreative 2008.

ImJustCreativeª is run by Graham Smith. A Seaford (East Sussex) Based Freelance Graphic & Web Designer who aims to Evolve Ideas to Print and Digital Media